Skip to Main Content

Predatory Publishing

This guide was created to help researchers to be aware of predatory publishers.

Introduction: Why Predatory Books and Chapters Matter to Researchers and Academia

Predatory book publishers exploit authors by charging fees without providing legitimate editorial and publishing services, undermining the integrity of scholarly communication. Understanding and identifying these deceptive practices is crucial for maintaining academic standards and protecting one's professional reputation.

What Are Predatory Books and Chapters, and How Do They Harm Researchers?

Predatory books and chapters are works published by entities that prioritize profit over scholarly integrity. These publishers often engage in deceptive practices, such as lacking rigorous peer review, providing minimal editorial oversight, and employing aggressive solicitation tactics. Their primary goal is financial gain rather than contributing to academic discourse.

Publication Ethics

How to Spot Predatory Books and Identify Legitimate Publishers

To discern reputable publications from predatory ones, consider the following:

  • Peer Review Process: Legitimate book publishers evaluate submissions thoroughly, typically involving reviewers with relevant expertise. Predatory book publishers may skip this step or use a superficial process.

    Publication Ethics

  • Editorial Board: Credible publishers are associated with recognised editors or editorial boards with expertise in the relevant field.

    Beall's List

  • Solicitation Practices: Predatory book publishers or editors may send aggressive emails soliciting chapters or manuscripts, often using overly positive language to entice submissions.

    UKSG

  • Fee Transparency: Reputable publishers clearly outline any fees, such as costs for open access publication or additional services. Predatory publishers often spring hidden fees after

    Beall's List

 

Why Authors Get Trapped by Predatory Publishers

Authors may be enticed by predatory publishers due to:

  • Pressure to Publish: The "publish or perish" culture in academia can lead authors to seek rapid publication avenues.

    BMC Medicine

  • Lack of Awareness: Early-career researchers may not be familiar with predatory practices and thus fall victim to deceptive solicitations.

    UKSG

  • Misleading Information: Predatory publishers often present themselves as legitimate, making it challenging to discern their true nature.

    Publication Ethics

What Happens When You Publish in Predatory Books or Chapters?

Consequences of Publishing in Predatory Books and Chapters

Engaging with predatory publishers can lead to:

  • Damage to Reputation: Associating with low-quality publications can harm an author's credibility.

    UKSG, 2024

  • Limited Dissemination: Predatory publications are often excluded from reputable academic databases, reducing the visibility of the work.

    Cambridge University Press

  • Financial Loss: Authors may incur significant fees without receiving legitimate publishing services.

    American Library Association

Resources to Help You Publish in Credible Books and Chapters

These resources focus on evaluating the quality and legitimacy of book publishers and chapter submissions.

  1. Think. Check. Submit. for Books

    • Description: An extension of the Think. Check. Submit. checklist designed for book authors.
    • Use: Helps assess the credibility of book publishers and chapter opportunities.
    • Access: Think. Check. Submit. for Books
  2. Directory of Open Access Books (DOAB)

    • Description: A directory of high-quality, peer-reviewed open-access books.
    • Use: Identify credible book publishers and validate book quality.
    • Access: Directory of Open Access Books
  3. Open Access Journal Quality Indicators

    • Description: Guidelines by Grand Valley State University for evaluating open-access publishers.
    • Use: Assess book or chapter publishers for quality and transparency.
    • Access: Open Access Journal Quality Indicators